Is Fluorocarbon Leader More Abrasion Resistant Than Traditional Mono Leader?

http://fluorocarbon%20line%20vs%20mono

It’s line testing time again!

And just wait until you see the video below with the somewhat shocking results

This latest test is directed at the commonly held belief that fluorocarbon leader is more resistant to abrasion than monofilament.

Based on feedback from the Salt Strong community, I tested the difference in abrasion between fluoro and mono for the following two scenarios:

  1. They both have the same rated strength (20 lbs)
  2. They both have the same diameter (20 lb mono vs. 25 lb fluoro)

And so far, this test has been the most shocking of all because my prior belief was completely thrown in the gutter.

Here’s the backstory:

Over the past couple of months, I started a quest to determine what the best line is in terms of its true value.

The overall goal of these experiments is to better understand the facts vs. the marketing-induced hype.

So far, some of the results have been very surprising because they completely uncovered some HUGE myths about our beloved fishing line.

And for me, this latest test is at the top of the list.

Line Testing Summary

After publishing several line analysis experiments using the testing platform shown below, the most common suggestion was to perform some tests on fluorocarbon line against traditional monofilament line.

So I began doing some research to see what the hype between the two lines seemed to be so that I could determine what tests to start out with.

So I’ll walk you through the thought entire process from test creation to final conclusion in this article.

But first, let’s quickly talk about a much-needed clarification:

What’s The Difference Between Fluorocarbon and Monofilament Fishing Line

monofilament vs fluorocarbon

This is a very common question that we receive, and the quick answer is that they both are monofilament lines.

Fluorocarbon line is just a subset of monofilament that is becoming more and more popular as of late.

It’s becoming so popular, that most people think of it as its own class of line… so I’ll frame this post as if they are two classes since they are most commonly thought of that way in terms of expected performance in addition to their perceived value and sticker price.

In general, fluorocarbon is favored by many anglers because it is commonly known to be superior to traditional monofilament line for the following core reasons:

  1. Less visible in the water – This claim is made mostly due to the density of fluorocarbon being closer to that of water which makes for less refraction of light. Fluoro typically has a thinner diameter relative to its strength, so that feeds into this core benefit as well.
  2. More resistant to abrasion – This claim seems to be made across the board, and I can only assume it’s due to simply equating that increased density means increased abrasion resistance [this is the factor that I examined in this test]
  3. Better performance characteristics – There seem to be a lot of hype around fluoro being better due to it having less stretch, a faster sinking rate, and a variety of other things that we’ll cover in a different post.

For now, let’s just focus on the abrasion characteristic because that’s what this latest experiment is all about.

Online Research Results On Fluoro vs. Mono Abrasion

Here are some snapshots of the information I found when performing some research online courtesy from our dear friends at Google.

The online reports seem to be overwhelmingly favorable to fluorocarbon when it comes to abrasion relative to monofilament line.

Here’s an example from a detailed post about fluorocarbon vs. mono line where it clearly shows that fluorocarbon is the superior choice due to its density/hardness:

image source: google.com

And here’s another top-rated result from the research where it states that fluorocarbon is more abrasion resistant than mono when their diameters are equal to one another… not quite as lofty a claim as before, but still very confidently showing fluoro as the superior line.

image source: google.com

I went through a good amount of articles, but never once did I see a test done on this important aspect of a leader line, so that’s when I just knew that I had to try it out even though the answer seemed so obvious…

So with that said, let’s dive into this latest experiment:

Is Fluorocarbon Leader Really More Abrasion Resistant Than Mono?

The test is shown in detail in the video below.

As you’ll see, I performed two tests isolating the following characteristics for the two tests:

  1. Rated Strength (2o lb leader lines used in this test)
  2. Line Diameter (resulted in a 20 lb mono going against a 25 lb fluorocarbon line)

Click the video below to see what happened:

Sign up for FREE to receive the latest saltwater fishing videos, tutorials, product reviews, and fishing product discounts!

Conclusion

After being blown away by the fact that the traditional monofilament line beating two different brands of fluorocarbon that was supposed to be stronger, I did some more research to see if I missed something.

One thing I found in this research was that monofilament can lose some of its strength after being submerged in water for an extended period of time.

So I soaked mono in water for over 15 minutes before testing it again against the same two fluorocarbon lines, and it still won by roughly the same margin.

Of course, this single test with just a few lines can’t prove once and for all if monofilament is or is not more abrasion resistant than fluorocarbon because I’m sure the results vary depending on the lines used…

But in my opinion, this experiment at least squashes the theory that fluorocarbon line are all stronger than monofilament lines.

There will be a lot more testing, so please let me know if you have any suggestions for improving the future experiments.

And let me know what lines you’d like me to try out as well.

Fish On!

P.S. – Please be sure to share this post with any of your friends who use fluorocarbon leaders so that they know their trusted leaders may not be as strong as they thought… this test sure made me reconsider the leaders that I use.

Related Posts:

See More Fishing Line Tests/Reviews

 

Related categories:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
190 Comments
newest
oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Andrew Collier
14 days ago

I guess like so many others looks like ,we all have been wasting money on a product that’s not superior. That’s for a true test, great work. Thanks.

Dave Adams
2 months ago

Are the results of using regular fishing line any different than using much more expensive leader line, either mono or floro?

tom hastings
3 months ago

Finally a no BS test! Kudos for taking the time & trouble to getting an answer.

Ryan
3 months ago

I have always thought Floro has seemed softer. I have a friend who a well respected materials engineer I will reach out to see what he thinks about this and your test.

Angelo
3 months ago

Hi Luke,
Nice video. It was a big surprise definitely.
Maybe you could do something similar using mono and Fluor from the same brand? Could the issue be in the brand of the Fluor line? Thanks for the video.

Rick Schwerdtfeger
3 months ago

Great video! As a scientist, I appreciate your objective approach, and the results certainly have statistical significance! But as a fisherman, quite frankly, I am more concerned about the visibility question than the abrasion question. Have you tested that?

Kendall
6 months ago

Awesome vid, definitely making the switch to mono-line leader. Thanks for the knowledge.

Last edited 6 months ago by Kendall
Mac
6 months ago

Never used fluorocarbon line, but if you are breaking off a lot of fish then you may have your drag set too tight. If you are a fresh water fisherman and switch to salt water, it’s a different game!

Robtard
6 months ago

Hey have you done this abrasion test with using braid? I know braid gets knocked on for not being too abrasion resistant but would be good to see an actual test. I just know when trying to cut braid line vs mono/fluoro it is much harder to do.

Matt
6 months ago

I watched this video and a few others on your YouTube channel. Thanks for the great content. I was considering putting fluoro on my ice fishing reels but after seeing this I’m reconsidering staying with mono.

STOP WASTING TIME ON THE WATER!

Do what the “SMART ANGLERS” are doing and join the Insider Club.

Here’s what you’ll receive today when you join:

Other Fishing Tips You May Like :

5 Saltwater Fishing Lures That Work Anywhere In The World

What are your top 5 favorite lures? Check this out to see which lures work worldwide, and what really matters when it comes to lure selection.
See Full post
17 comments

The Ugly Truth About Big Sugar Destroying Florida’s Coastline…

If you want to see the ulgy truth about algae blooms, big sugar, and Florida's ongoing water issues, then you've got to see this documentary.
See Full post
23 comments
190
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x