Aggressive vs. Finicky Redfish: How To Catch Redfish In Every Situation


When a school of redfish is aggressively feeding, it’s game on!

You can catch fish after fish and it makes you feel like you’ve finally cracked the code on how to become a master angler.

But then the conditions change, the bite turns off, and you wonder what happened…

Are they full now?

Did they move?

This can be so frustrating!

I was in this exact situation on the trip shown below when I went out fishing with two other Insider Club members.

Early in the morning the fish were very aggressive, but as the sun came up and the conditions changed, we had to make a change to the game plan to catch more redfish.

How to Catch Redfish In Every Situation [VIDEO]

Sign up for FREE to receive the latest saltwater fishing videos, tutorials, product reviews, and fishing product discounts!


How To Find & Catch Aggressive Fish

Yes, it’s easy to catch fish when they’re aggressively feeding, but here’s the hard part: finding fish that are aggressively feeding.

When you get out on the water first thing in the morning, your main goal is to find fish.

To do that, you need to cover a lot of ground.

Throwing lures helps here, especially if you’re new to an area, as soaking a bait and waiting for fish to come by is much slower.

As you’re moving, keep your eyes open and look for things like:

  • Fish wakes
  • Scared/nervous baitfish
  • Redfish tails

On this trip, we paddled around until we started seeing some activity.

By staying on the go, we were able to find an active school of redfish.

As far as catching these fish, the key is to cover water quickly to increase the odds that your lure is seen by as many of the active redfish as possible.

I was using the Slam Shady paddletail during this period because it can be retrieved quickly while it gives off good vibration and scent (all of which combine to make for some fun fish catching).

How To Find & Catch Spooky Fish

As the day went on here, the fish went from hitting everything in sight, to being finicky and spooky.

The sun was shining bright. There were no clouds or wind, and the water was very clear, which is the perfect recipe for a tough day of fishing.

The redfish were so finicky that we were no longer able to use paddletails because even the relatively light vibrations compared to many other lures were spooking the fish, so we had to change our plan.

We paddled the shallow flats until we saw some good looking zones off in the distance, then we got out of our kayaks and waded quietly towards them.

We also changed our lures.

Instead of throwing the paddletails that give off a lot of vibration, we changed to jerk shads rigged on a 1/16 oz weighted hook.

With us being extra stealthy in our approach and lures, we were able to get back on the fish and start catching nearly as many fish as we caught in the morning when they were being extra aggressive.


how to catch spooky redfish

No matter if the fish are obviously aggressive, or extra skittish, you can still catch them by using the right tactics.

If they’re aggressively feeding, toss out a paddletail and hold on.

If they’re skittish, get out of the boat, wade to the fish, and toss out a jerk shad.

Here are the two lures I recommend always having on board with you:

And if you want to see exactly where we were fishing, plus get discounts to our online tackle store and the lures mentioned above, click here to join us in the Insider Club!

Related articles:

Related categories:

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Michael Fee
3 years ago

Hello all. Just wondering if you tried the slam shady with the paddle cut off before going to the split tail?

Mike Ratterman
3 years ago

What kind of paddle board was that? Never seen one like that before. Looks a lot more stable.

Gary Rankel
3 years ago

I just couldn’t win today. Ran into a bunch of finicky reds, and then returned home to a finicky wife!

Dan Foster
3 years ago

Great video Luke. A good example of adjusting to the situation! 

Caden Kaufman
3 years ago

What lure should I use at night?

Caden Kaufman
3 years ago
Reply to  Luke Simonds

Thanks! Would a bass buzzbait with a cloche minnow work

Caden Kaufman
3 years ago
Reply to  Caden Kaufman

Cocahoe minniow trailer

Caden Kaufman
3 years ago
Reply to  Luke Simonds


Caden Kaufman
3 years ago

What is the difference between split tail jerk baits and straight tail jerk baits.

Caden Kaufman
3 years ago
Reply to  Luke Simonds


3 years ago
Reply to  Luke Simonds

Good point!

James Prescott
3 years ago

What a great day Luke! Once the bite slowed down and you switched to the jerk bait you started crushing it! I wasn’t waiting! When I switched to what you were using I started catching too! Not sure who caught the most, but I think you edged Ed and I out!! 😁

3 years ago

Hey Luke, another great video. I was wondering what is your comfortable range or miles on your paddleboard versus a kayak and what effect does tide and wind play on how far away from the boat ramp or put in is possible? Thanks.

Stan Mitchell
3 years ago

WOW Awesome day on the water guys!!! Red fish 💪

3 years ago



Do what the “SMART ANGLERS” are doing and join the Insider Club.

Here’s what you’ll receive today when you join:

Other Fishing Tips You May Like :

Strong Angler Of The Week: Andy Atzhorn

Check out this story of Andy beating his personal best redfish TWICE, and his girlfriend DOUBLING the size of her previous personal best redfish!
See Full post
1 comment

Deadline To Pre-Order Salt Strong Slam T-Shirt Is TODAY!!

If you want more Salt Strong clothing, you better hurry to the store!! Salt Strong SLAM T-Shirts available until midnight tonight...
See Full post
No comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x

Get Instant Access To “The Inshore Fishing Manifesto” PDF Now

You’ll automatically be emailed a private link to download your PDF, plus you’ll be added to the Salt Strong Newsletter.
(Please double-check your email below to ensure delivery.)