When Should You Downsize Your Lures in the Fall?
- By: Tony Acevedo
- on
- Found In: Fishing Tips, Inshore Fishing, Tips for Fall Fishing, Tackle & Gear
Fall is one of my favorite times to throw bigger lures for redfish, trout, and snook.
With larger baitfish becoming more prevalent, upsizing your lure can be a great way to target hungry fish.
But does that mean you should ALWAYS be throwing big lures in the fall?
Absolutely not!
There are certain situations where downsizing your lure can actually give you a better chance of getting strikes, even when there’s plenty of big bait around.
The trick is knowing when the conditions call for something smaller instead of automatically reaching for a bigger lure.
Insiders: The Skinny Lipper Jr. is this month’s Tackle Tester! Be sure to claim yours while it’s available!
Featured Gear:
1. When You’re Fishing Around Schools of BIG Mullet
This is one situation that catches a lot of anglers off guard.
During the fall, you’ll often find large schools of mullet moving through the shallows. And I’m not talking about little finger mullet. I’m talking about mullet that are 12 to 15 inches long!
Now, you might think seeing all that big bait means it’s time to tie on the biggest lure in your tackle box.
But here’s something to consider.
Those big mullet can actually be too large for the redfish and trout hanging around them to eat.
So why are the predator fish there?
As those mullet move along the bottom, they stir up smaller baitfish, shrimp, and other food that nearby predators can take advantage of.
In other words, the fish aren’t necessarily trying to eat the big mullet. They’re taking advantage of the feeding opportunities those schools create.
That’s exactly the type of situation I was fishing in this video.
I started with a smaller Skinny Lipper Jr. and was able to hook into a nice redfish.
It’s a perfect reminder that just because you’re seeing BIG bait doesn’t automatically mean you need a BIG lure.
2. When the Water Is Calm and Clear
Another situation where I like to downsize is when the water gets really calm and clear.
In those conditions, fish can get a much better look at your lure.
A large, aggressive presentation might work great when there’s some chop or the water is dirty, but it won’t always get the same reaction when everything is calm.
That’s when I’ll often switch to something with a smaller profile and a more subtle presentation.
The Skinny Lipper Jr. is a good example.
It’s a small, lipped hardbait that dives roughly a foot or two below the surface when you retrieve it. When you pause, it floats back toward the top.
I like to work it with a couple of twitches followed by a pause, letting that rising action help trigger strikes.
You can also retrieve it steadily, almost like a shallow-running crankbait.
The key is to pay attention to how the fish respond and adjust your retrieve accordingly.
Sometimes, a smaller lure with a little less commotion is exactly what those fish want.
3. After a Cold Front When Fish Aren’t Chasing
Fall fishing can be fantastic, but those cold fronts can definitely change how fish behave.
You might have a great bite going one day, only to come back after a front and find bright blue skies, high pressure, and fish that don’t seem interested in chasing anything.
This is another time when downsizing can make a big difference.
Rather than continuing to throw a larger lure and hoping the fish eventually commit, I’ll often switch to a smaller profile and slow down my presentation.
The goal is to make the lure easier for those less-aggressive fish to eat without requiring them to chase it very far.
That doesn’t mean bigger lures suddenly stop working after every cold front.
But when the fish aren’t responding, downsizing is one of the first adjustments I’d consider.
Sometimes, that simple change is all it takes to turn a frustrating trip around.
Final Thoughts
There’s a good reason we recommend throwing bigger lures in the fall. Larger baitfish are often more abundant, and actively feeding predators can be willing to chase bigger meals.
But bigger isn’t ALWAYS better.
If you’re fishing around oversized mullet, dealing with calm and clear water, or struggling to get bites after a cold front, don’t be afraid to downsize.
Pay attention to the conditions, the available food, and how the fish are behaving.
The best lure isn’t necessarily the biggest one. It’s the one that fits the situation you’re fishing.
And if you’re struggling to find fish in the first place, check out the Salt Strong Insider Club. With Smart Fishing Spots, fishing courses, and a community of anglers sharing what’s working, you’ll have more tools to help you get on fish.
Have you had better luck throwing smaller lures in the fall, or do you usually stick with bigger presentations? Let me know in the comments!
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I use big or small lures in the fall?
Bigger lures are often a great starting point in the fall because larger baitfish are more prevalent and predator fish may be feeding aggressively. However, downsizing can be more effective in certain situations, especially around oversized bait, in calm and clear water, or after a cold front.
Why would redfish eat smaller lures around big mullet?
Large mullet can stir up smaller food sources as they move along the bottom. Redfish and trout may follow those schools to take advantage of that food rather than trying to eat the big mullet themselves.
Should I downsize my lures after a cold front?
It’s a good adjustment to try when fish become less aggressive. A smaller lure with a slower, more subtle presentation can be easier to get a reaction from when fish aren’t willing to chase larger offerings.
What’s a good smaller lure for fall redfish?
The Skinny Lipper Jr. is one option, especially when fishing shallow water. Its diving and floating action allows you to experiment with twitch-and-pause retrieves or a steady retrieve to see what triggers strikes.
Related categories:
STOP WASTING TIME ON THE WATER!
Do what the “SMART ANGLERS” are doing and join the Insider Club.
Here’s what you’ll receive today when you join:
- Weekly fishing reports and TRENDS revealing exactly where you should fish ever trip
- Weekly “spot dissection” videos that walk you through all the best spots in your area
- Exclusive fishing tips from the PROS you can’t find anywhere else
- Everything you need to start catching fish more consistently (regardless if you fish out of a boat, kayak, or land).
STOP WASTING TIME ON THE WATER!
Do what the “SMART ANGLERS” are doing and join the Insider Club.
Here’s what you’ll receive today when you join:
- Weekly fishing reports and TRENDS revealing exactly where you should fish every trip
- Weekly “spot dissection” videos that walk you through all the best spots in your area
- Exclusive fishing tips from the PROS you can’t find anywhere else
- Everything you need to start catching fish more consistently (regardless if you fish out of a boat, kayak, or land).



Great info. Thanks
Great points Tony obviously a fish that’s 15 inches and larger is much to big to eat from both a very large redfish or big gator trout and while they can eat very large baitfish I’m sure even though they are only fish they know there limitations I have also noticed that after seeing a lot of sting rays that there movement in areas can have the same effect as big mullet moving through especially considering that stingrays especially are ALWAYS directly on the bottom so there wings will have a greater effect on stirring up the bottom maybe even more so then mullet because mullet jump alot but either way both being observed can have the same effect as the other i usually mostly go by the water temperature in determining when to downsize once the water temps start to drop into the 60s that’s my cue on starting to use smaller lures until the late spring when the baitfish start to get bigger and also like you said cold fronts as well in fact during this transitional period from fall to winter I usually have both large and small lures rigged and whatever conditions are in play for that trip t adjust to it and at least have a general idea of usually what the fish prefer if you would on your next weekend game plan if you would mention the water temps for Jacksonville area waters that would help me out alot because I don’t go out except every other week so I don’t know the conditions of the water unless someone tells me and you being a coach are out on it alot more then me considering its your job anyways great info as usual Tony thanks for it and as usual all you do🤔😉👍
Great video Tony. Thanks for clarifying when to go small.
Thanks Tony. I have an area just like this with big mullet and I never seem to catch much. Looks like a textbook spot with a deep drop off next to the flats where the mullets hang. Lot of current also. Catch mostly small groupers on the drop off and nothing on the mullet flats area, so frustrating. Will be trying the skinny jr on the next time out.
You’re welcome David!
Thanks Tony. This is great info to store away for future use.
You’re welcome T!